All Cast
Madelaine Petsch
Maya
Richard Brake
Sheriff Rotter
Ema Horvath
Shelly / Pinup
Gabriel Basso
Gregory / Scarecrow
Pedro Leandro
Deputy Walters
Rachel Shenton
Debbie
George Young
Howard
Kyle Breitkopf
Teenage Gregory / Scarecrow
Finn Cofell
Teenage Pinup
Stevee Davies
Dougie
Hannah Galway
Claire
Sara Freedland
Annie
Dani Klupsch
Carrie
Ella Bruccoleri
Jasmine
Krystal Ellsworth
Dollface
Janis Ahern
Carol
Pablo Sandstrom
Neil
Stephanie Aubertin
Teenage Dollface
Nicholas Chaif
Sleazy Guy
Jake Cogman
Young Scarecrow
Leo Petrus
Judge
Canaan Davison
Teenage Lumberjack
Nola Wallace
Young Pinup
Ben Cartwright
Rudy
Joel Labelle
Man